HIV is it a crime?

Let me put a serious delema on this community to justify this section

Is it a crime if someone HIV positive has sex wo protection with an HIV negative?

My personal opinion is no. ad there r many reasons.

1)A sexual act is between 2(or more!) people therefore one cannot take more responsibility than the other about sexual health and protection. If it happened it s both of the two fault.
2)If it s a crime to have sex as an hiv possitive then it s also a crime to sneeze if u have the flu H1N1 in example.
3)There are no means to prove one got HIV from a particular person
4)Criminalizing a virus and its carriers offers a poor sollution versus the disease because it creates an unessasary fear and panic, therefore ppl that know they r possitive will hide it even more, and ppl that suspect they could be possitive will be in fear to take the tests. Especially since the fatality of the virus with proper treatment limits close to 0

I ll add a poll

 

Yes it is a Crime Period

If I had HIV and I go traveling the world ****ing everything that moves infecting everybody Im giving them Death on the long run

 

If you are knowingly giving someone a disease with a near 100% fatality rate, you are essentially murdering them. I don't see how this question could possibly be argued otherwise.

 

That fear and missinformation I m trying to battle...

No ofc not. Your allover the world partners could use protection and protect themselves. And death no many people live with the virus and they even make families one parent positive other negative

 

How about unknowingly?

You can't stop the human body from carrying out what it's supposed to do: Survive and breed.
Not when you don't feel anything weird about you at all.

 

another missinformed... it s a shame...
HIV has close to 0/100 fatality with modern treatments. Furthermore sexual protection is a responsibility of both partners not just 1

 

If it isn't 0% then there's still a chance and that's still endangering someone's life.

 

Not all who have been infected can afford the treatment, so it's still a large percentage of people dying out there.

As for the protection, humans just can't resist temptations/misinformation/etc. that can lead to its demise after all.

 

It is a crime if you dont let your partner known about it or the person you gona have x without protection.

 

"It's not my fault she didn't make me use a condom!"

Is this seriously your argument? Really? If so I'm actually worried for your sanity.

Hence why I voted the middle option. If you don't know, you don't know. Bad things happen without intent, and that's just the way it goes sometimes.

 

But if u tell ur partner he/she would probably avoid sexual intercourse even with protection exactly because of the fear society has about AIDS.

 

Because condoms work 100% of the time. They never fail.

 

exactly...but what can i say...u probably so naive and outdated that u probably think it s the man s responsibility to use condom. And I said many more things which u just ignored, like there is no possible way to prove one gave u hiv

The middle opinion is the obvious reject for in law there is this difference between willing and unwilling crime (but both are named crimes) so u either think it s a crime or not

 

I agree, that it can be crime only if the infected knows he's/she's infected and about to infect another one...
but for those how are not? its kinda complicated situation.....

But
for the majority of the mankind, it cannot be crime..........

unless its like the scenario in "Left 4 dead"^_^v

Be responsible... Safe Sex.....

"The reproductive bill"<<< is about to be implemented on our country....
and one of the most grueling battle of the christian parish on the our government....

 

agreed.....................

 

So you don't think it's a crime if someone intentionally gives someone a disease?

 

bad luck, its your partner's decision not you.

 

nope because one cannot!! unless it s a rape as well or a direct injection of the virus or infected blood in the bloodstream.

 

yes son it is a crime.... it's like serving a food with a poison in it...

 

but society shouldn t fear hiv